Customs Today
  • Home
  • Islamabad
  • Karachi
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
No Result
View All Result
Customs Today
  • Home
  • Islamabad
  • Karachi
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
No Result
View All Result
Customs Today
No Result
View All Result
Home Breaking News

FBR fails to submit reply in LHC petition against reward scheme

byCT Report
04/05/2026
in Breaking News, Lahore, Latest News, Slider News
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

LAHORE: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has yet to file written comments before the Lahore High Court (LHC) in a constitutional petition challenging the legality of its peer-ranking reward scheme.

The petition, filed by Advocate Waheed Shahzad Butt through constitutional expert Muhammad Azhar Siddique, invokes Article 199 and questions the validity of the Inland Revenue (IR) Reward Rules and Customs Reward Rules.

You might also like

Iran-US conflict pushes Karachi-Gulf shipping costs higher

16/11/2026

Sohail Chaudhary to lead ICCI’s Int’l trade promotion initiatives

16/11/2026

It argues that these provisions have enabled what it describes as an “unregulated and unconstitutional distribution” of millions of rupees from the public exchequer to selected FBR officials, allegedly without clear legal backing, transparent criteria, or parliamentary oversight.

The LHC had issued notices to multiple respondents, including senior government officials such as the Prime Minister’s Secretariat, FBR leadership, members of the Policy Board, federal ministers, parliamentary finance committees, the Auditor General of Pakistan, and the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA).

All were directed to submit detailed replies addressing the constitutional and legal concerns raised in the petition.

Commenting on the delay, Waheed Butt said the FBR’s silence raises serious concerns, noting that an institution responsible for enforcing tax laws appears unable to justify the distribution of taxpayer funds under its internal reward system.

At the center of the case is the peer-ranking reward scheme, under which tax officials reportedly receive financial incentives based on rankings assigned by their colleagues. The petitioner argues that such a closed-loop system is vulnerable to favoritism and lacks institutional transparency.

The petition further maintains that these payouts, drawn from public funds, do not meet constitutional requirements, lack statutory authorization, and operate outside approved parliamentary appropriations and accountability frameworks—potentially placing significant public money beyond legislative scrutiny and audit.

Legal experts, civil society groups, and fiscal watchdogs are closely following the case, particularly given the inclusion of oversight bodies like the Auditor General and FIA as respondents, highlighting the broader accountability implications.

The petitioner warned that if the Court rules the scheme unconstitutional, it could have far-reaching consequences for how the FBR designs incentive structures and manages public funds. For now, the FBR’s failure to respond continues to draw attention as proceedings move forward.

Related Stories

Iran-US conflict pushes Karachi-Gulf shipping costs higher

byCT Report
16/11/2026

LAHORE: The repercussions of the Iran-US conflict are beginning to affect regional trade, with shipping costs from Pakistan's Port of...

Sohail Chaudhary to lead ICCI’s Int’l trade promotion initiatives

byCT Report
16/11/2026

ISLAMABAD: President Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ICCI) Muhammad Zikria Akbar Zia has appointed Executive Member Muhammad Sohail Chaudhary...

Quetta Enforcement foils bid to smuggle 115kg of opium worth Rs585m

byCT Report
16/11/2026

QUETTA: Collectorate of Customs Enforcement has foiled an attempt to smuggle narcotics by recovering 115 kilograms of opium worth an...

Finance Minister reviews progress on SME Connect Portal and export finance initiatives

byCT Report
16/11/2026

ISLAMABAD- November 16,2026: Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue, Senator Muhammad Aurangzeb, chaired a meeting to discuss ongoing efforts to...

Next Post

FBR clears long-pending tax refund within three weeks on FTO orders

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer

© 2011 Customs Today -World's first newspaper on customs. Customs Today.

No Result
View All Result
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Latest News
  • Karachi
  • Islamabad
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
  • About Us

© 2011 Customs Today -World's first newspaper on customs. Customs Today.