MULTAN: The Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue (ATIR), Multan Bench, has taken serious notice of an alleged fake adjournment recorded by an FBR assessing officer to extend the statutory time limit for completing tax adjudication proceedings.
In a significant ruling, the tribunal declared an assessment order time-barred after finding that the taxpayer had not actually requested the 30-day adjournment recorded in the official proceedings. The decision also highlights the importance of maintaining accurate and transparent records during tax adjudication.
The landmark judgment was authored by a bench comprising Khurram Shahbaz Butt and Naveed Zafar Khan, which also directed that a copy of the order be sent to the Chief Commissioner Inland Revenue for information and appropriate action under the law.
The case arose when Muhammad Imran Ghazi, counsel for the appellant taxpayer, challenged the assessment order before ATIR on the grounds that it had been issued beyond the statutory limitation period.
The taxpayer’s counsel argued that the 30-day adjournment mentioned in the adjudication record had never been requested by the taxpayer or its authorised representatives.
Taking notice of the allegation, ATIR directed the concerned assessing officer to appear personally before the tribunal along with the relevant adjudication record.
Affidavit Contradicts FBR Officer’s Official Record
During examination of the case, the tribunal reviewed the order sheet maintained by the assessing officer.
According to the official record, on November 20, 2025, the officer had recorded that Muhammad Amir, a partner of the appellant firm, appeared during the proceedings and requested a 30-day adjournment, which was subsequently granted.
However, the taxpayer produced an affidavit sworn by Aamer Tufail Warraich, son of Muhammad Tufail Warraich, Managing Partner of the appellant firm.
The affidavit categorically denied the officer’s claim, stating that neither Aamer Tufail Warraich nor any partner, employee or authorised representative of the firm had appeared or requested an adjournment on November 20, 2025.
It further stated that no oral or written adjournment request had been submitted and that no document or order sheet relating to such a request had been signed by any representative of the taxpayer.
After receiving the taxpayer’s affidavit, ATIR directed the assessing officer to submit a counter-affidavit to respond to the allegations.
However, the assessing officer failed to provide the required counter-affidavit.
After examining the available record and the evidence presented by the taxpayer, the tribunal concluded that no adjournment had actually been requested on November 20, 2025.
Consequently, the tribunal held that the assessment order, having been passed after the expiry of the statutory 180-day period from the issuance of the show-cause notice, was time-barred.
In its judgment, the tribunal emphasised that maintaining accurate and contemporaneous records is fundamental to ensuring fair tax adjudication.
ATIR observed that any entry in the official proceedings that extends the statutory limitation period to the disadvantage of a taxpayer requires the highest level of care, accuracy and integrity.
The tribunal stated that the authenticity of adjudication records is essential for protecting taxpayers’ legal rights and ensuring transparency in proceedings conducted by tax authorities.
Considering the seriousness of the matter, ATIR directed that a copy of its order be forwarded to the Chief Commissioner Inland Revenue for information and any action considered appropriate in accordance with the law.
The development raises questions about the accuracy of official adjudication records and the accountability of tax officers responsible for maintaining them.
Commenting on the decision, tax consultant Shahid Jami appreciated the recent judgments being delivered by newly appointed ATIR members, stating that their experience in tax laws was contributing to fairer decisions and the development of important legal precedents for taxpayers across Pakistan.
He also questioned whether the FBR Chairman would take action against the concerned assessing officer over the alleged manipulation of official records, particularly in light of four cases reportedly identified by ATIR.
The ruling reinforces the principle that tax authorities cannot rely on unsupported adjournment entries to extend statutory limitation periods or justify otherwise time-barred assessment proceedings.






