Customs Today
  • Home
  • Islamabad
  • Karachi
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
No Result
View All Result
Customs Today
  • Home
  • Islamabad
  • Karachi
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
No Result
View All Result
Customs Today
No Result
View All Result
Home Breaking News

Supreme Court rules in favour of Coca-Cola in tax dispute with FBR

byCT Report
14/11/2025
in Breaking News, Islamabad, Latest News
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled in favour of Coca-Cola Pakistan Limited, dismissing the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) stance in a long-running tax apportionment dispute dating back to the tax year 2003.

In a detailed judgment authored by Justice Muneeb Akhtar and concurred by Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui and Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb, the apex court held that there is no mandatory or exclusive formula for apportioning expenses among different income sources. Instead, such allocation may be made on “any reasonable basis” under the law.

You might also like

SMEDA announces Rs5m matching grants for SMEs

17/11/2026

Online customs valuation hearings to begin at Lahore: FBR Chairman

17/11/2026

The dispute arose after the FBR claimed that Coca-Cola Pakistan failed to allocate its expenses in accordance with Income Tax Rule 13, and therefore reassessed the company’s tax liability. However, the Supreme Court ruled that if a taxpayer’s method of allocation is reasonable and justifiable, it cannot be rejected merely because it differs from the FBR’s formula.

The judgment clarified that under Section 67(1) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, taxpayers are required to allocate expenses reasonably, but the rules issued by the FBR are not absolute or binding. Justice Akhtar emphasized that the law allows flexibility—different reasonable methods may coexist, even if they diverge from the FBR’s approach.

Coca-Cola Pakistan had used the Gross Profit Ratio (GPR) method for expense allocation, which the court deemed to be a reasonable basis. Consequently, the FBR’s amended assessment was declared legally unsustainable, and the Lahore High Court’s earlier judgment was set aside.

The decision is seen as a significant precedent for corporate taxpayers, reaffirming that the FBR’s procedural rules cannot override statutory principles of reasonableness under the Income Tax Ordinance.

Related Stories

SMEDA announces Rs5m matching grants for SMEs

byCT Report
17/11/2026

LAHORE: The Small and Medium Enterprises Development Authority (SMEDA), under the Ministry of Industries and Production, has invited applications from...

Online customs valuation hearings to begin at Lahore: FBR Chairman

byCT Report
17/11/2026

LAHORE: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial said on Tuesday that a dedicated online hearing room for...

Indus Enforcement seizes smuggled goods worth Rs680m in Kalabagh

byCT Report
17/11/2026

KALA BAGH: Collectorate of Indus Enforcement, customs teams raided a dumping site in Missile Colony, Kala Bagh and seized smuggled...

Karachi Enforcement impounds two tankers carrying Iranian fuel worth Rs50.51m

byCT Report
17/11/2026

KARACHI: Collectorate of Customs Enforcement officers seized two tankers loaded with Iranian petrol and diesel in Karachi. The total value...

Next Post

FBR assigns 76 surplus employees from various ministries

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer

© 2011 Customs Today -World's first newspaper on customs. Customs Today.

No Result
View All Result
  • Transfers and Postings
  • Latest News
  • Karachi
  • Islamabad
  • Lahore
  • National
  • Chambers & Associations
  • Business
  • About Us

© 2011 Customs Today -World's first newspaper on customs. Customs Today.